Reading Between the Tags: A Year of Writing Only for People Who Press Ctrl+U
Photo: User:Bluemoose, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Last November I deleted my website. Not the files — the visible part. I stripped every paragraph, every image, every link off the page and moved the entire thing into HTML comments, the bracketed little asides that browsers skip right past.
What a visitor saw was this: a title, a horizontal rule, and one line of text. Everything is in the comments. View source.
That was it. For a year.
The Mechanics of Being Nowhere
Comments are the oldest form of hiding in the language. <!-- like this -->. They were invented so developers could leave notes for each other, and almost immediately repurposed by people leaving notes for nobody in particular: jokes, timestamps, apologies, the classic if you're reading this, you have too much time on your hands.
My site became a stack of them. Navigation was a comment. Fourteen essays were comments. The image links were comments. There was a block at the bottom listing every domain I'd ever owned, and a block above it containing a fairly embarrassing list of resolutions for a year that is now safely in the past.
Because comments don't render, the page loaded instantly and weighed almost nothing. It was the fastest my site has ever been. It was also, by any reasonable measure, empty.
Two Hundred and Fourteen People Looked
I embedded a link, deep in the source, past the essays, that went to a page only reachable from there. Clicking it logged a visit. Over twelve months, 214 people clicked it.
That's a rounding error compared to my traffic. But 214 is not nothing. It's a small theater. It's a couple of college lecture halls. It's everyone who has ever waited for you in an airport terminal.
About a third clicked within ten seconds of arriving, which tells me they didn't need the instruction — they'd already opened the source on reflex. The rest took minutes, and I like to imagine them reading the note, sighing, and going to find the menu.
Desktop browsers accounted for nearly all of it. On mobile, opening the source requires a chain of taps most people don't know exists, and only about a dozen visitors made it through that gauntlet.
What They Left Behind
Some of the clickers emailed me. That correspondence is the best thing I own.
One man sent a screenshot of a comment he'd found in the source of a university department page in 2004 and had saved ever since. It read: Dave — the grant numbers changed, do not use the old ones, I'm serious this time. He had no idea who Dave was.
A woman sent me a comment she found on a bank's homepage — a cheerful note from 2011 explaining that a menu item was broken and would be fixed by Friday.
Someone else pasted me their own site's source, which contained a to-do list last touched in 2009: fix footer, call Mom, buy new router.
Three people left me gifts in the form of ASCII art, one of which is a genuinely decent cat. Two wrote haiku. One person's only message was a single line: I read all of it. You should be embarrassed about paragraph nine. I was.
The Slow Death of a Reflex
There was a moment — and I am not romanticizing it, I promise — when viewing the source of a page was a normal thing to do. It's how a generation learned to make websites, by stealing politely from people who did it better. Webrings and guestbooks and hidden frames and little messages for the curious were all built on the assumption that somebody might look under the hood.
That assumption is going away. Pages are rendered now, not written. Bundles and frameworks and layers of script have made the source a machine's document rather than a human's. The View Source menu item has been quietly demoted in most browsers. Nobody's kids are learning HTML by peeking at a Neopets profile anymore.
Which is fine. Things end. But there was a specific kind of intimacy in it that I miss, and I didn't know how much until I spent a year depending on it.
The Intimacy of the Source
Writing for the source is different from writing for the page. It's like leaving a letter in a book at a used bookstore and knowing exactly how few people will find it.
You can be more honest in a comment. You can be worse, too — sloppier, weirder, more sentimental — because you know the audience is self-selected and tiny. There's no SEO in there. No scroll depth. Just a person who knows where to look, reading something you wrote for them and nobody else.
I kept a running comment for the whole year that said, simply: if you're here, say hello. Thirty-one people did.
Un-Hiding
In November I moved everything back out into the light. The site looks normal again. It also looks, to me, a little louder than it needs to be.
I left one comment in the source, at the very bottom of the page. It's still there. It isn't hard to find.